Resisting Presentation Mediocrity: The Importance of Preparation


Hearing someone say “I’m just going to wing it” sends me into a state of panic.  Students who don’t prepare or practice for their presentation do not do well; there has never been “wing it” situation gone right.

Surprisingly, even in the high-stakes business world, few presenters truly invest the time they should to 1) preparing for their content/message, 2) designing effective, audience-centered slides, and 3) practicing their delivery/putting all three “legs” of the presentation ecosystem together.  As Nancy Duarte explains in her book Slide:ology, an essential element of preparation includes feedback and constructive criticism.  But how much time do we actually spend preparing?  And why should we prepare when everyone else around us doesn’t prepare?



My students deliver presentations almost every single month that they attend school.  That means they come to my class with a slew of bad habits that take time and effort to correct.

First, since their other instructors aren’t presentation experts, the bar is often set very low for these students.  The students can “wing it” and make an “A” because the instructors haven’t studied, taught, lived, and breathed public speaking and presentation.  Usually, if the content is there, and if all of the content is written out on the slides, the instructor feels the student did his or her job.  Sadly, this perpetuates mediocre, selfish presenting as opposed to audience-centered presenting that will resonate.

Also, since the students who spend hours and hours on preparation earn the same grades as the students who “wing it,” my hard-working students become frustrated that their efforts don’t actually pay off in other classes.  If a student is being graded on how well he or she can write a script out on a slideshow, turn around, and read those slides, why present in an effective way?  If a boring, standard, death-by-PowerPoint earns an “A,” why bother presenting any other way?

Third, the students see terrible presentations every single day at school.  Most students complain that their teachers bore them to tears using death-by-bulletpoint slides and the standard, sterile lecture format.  Why should the students work hard to develop strong presentations when their own teachers don’t prepare themselves?

These are questions I am faced with each time I get a new batch of Professional Communication and Presentation students.  And, ultimately, the students are faced with a choice.  They can a) completely transform the way they communicate and speak to an audience or they can b) continue being mediocre.

Most people opt for mediocrity.  Andrew Dlugan examines the public speaking bell curve in “Average Speakers Suck.  Don’t Be Average.”  Dlugan explains that, while it’s okay to be “average” on the bell curve of height or of golf-playing ability, if you are an average speaker, you suck.



So, yes, most speakers suck.  Most presentations suck.  Most people revel in their mediocrity and have no problem with their average-ness.  Dlugan writes, “Why is the average speaker so bad? Like golf, most people in the world never receive any formal communications training, and they never pursue any informal training either. We all pay the price. Think of the last 50 presentations you have attended. How many kept you interested throughout? Ten? Five? Fewer than five?” (Source).

I explain to my students that if they want to, they can give into mediocrity.  Being mediocre is so easy!  After all, anyone can present an average speech.  However, my students can also decide NOT to be mediocre.  They can decide to work to become strong, powerful, effective presenters, and the first step to delivering a message that resonates is to focus on preparation.

How do you resist the constant tug of presentation mediocrity?


3 thoughts on “Resisting Presentation Mediocrity: The Importance of Preparation

  1. Amen to everything you’ve written. I could write pages and pages here in the comments section, but I’ll try to be succinct. One of the things I’ve been able to get my colleagues to agree to at work is a “dressed rehearsal day” on the eve of any major meeting or conference we organize. Last year was the first year we implemented it, and it was eye opening (and a bit of a disaster) on the first go – a lot of “death by PPT” and too little time to fix it. We’ve continued this dressed rehearsal habit over the course of the past year. Last week, in preparation for a major presentation in India, the dressed rehearsal went well and the 2-day meeting was phenomenal – engaging, interactive, well-rehearsed delivery. Anyways, thanks for the post on a very important topic – when it comes to your high achieving students who take the time to form good presenting habits – let them know that once the grades have faded away, the true measure of success will be on the feedback they get when presenting in front of their boss or clients or other people who may reward them not with grades but rather riches and fame (or at least good job evaluations and increased opporutnities for high profile roles).

  2. Reblogged this on Train Like A Champion and commented:
    The Train Like a Champion blog is taking a little time off this week, recovering from jetlag. But this recent post by Alex Rister’s “Creating Communication” blog struck me – preparation is essential in advance of a presentation. I couldn’t have written on the topic any better!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s